Monday, November 16, 2026

Skeptics Fail Dismally Trying to Explain Away Mysterious Striped Orbs

When skeptics get evidence for things they cannot explain, they typically try to use one-word or two-word phrases to try to explain things. So if someone reports seeing an apparition, the skeptic will immediately yell, "Hallucination!"  Such an explanation does not work to explain the many cases in which multiple people have reported seeing the same apparition. You can read about such cases in my series of posts below.

When Multiple Witnesses See the Same Apparition



To try to explain away mysterious orbs appearing in photos, skeptics typically shout: "Dust!" The explanation does not work, because photos showing mysterious orbs are almost never taken in dusty conditions; and the dust in ordinary air is way too small to produce mysterious orbs in photos. 

The size of particles floating in the air is settled science widely used by air quality experts, pollution experts, and meteorologists. Scientists have electronic instruments that allow them to measure such particle widths very exactly. Do a Google search for “particle size chart” and you will get quite a few charts that all give pretty much the same numbers (such as those shown in this wikipedia.org article on particulates).

There is general agreement about the following particle size estimates, although estimates may vary by as much as 50%. A micron is a thousandth of a millimeter, or a millionth of a meter. You can find many charts like the one below by doing a Google image search for "particle size chart."


Condition of airParticle size
Outdoor air, dry1 micron
Indoors, normal10 microns
Indoor dust spikes (vacuuming, etc.)50 microns
Outdoor heavy smog30 microns
Heavy fog, mist500 microns
Heavy visible dust in air, reducing visibility500 microns
Rain1000 microns or more

Now let's plug these numbers into a spreadsheet that computes the blockage fraction, which means the percentage of a camera lens blocked by a particle. The spreadsheet is below. The numbers in the fourth column are simply the numbers in the second column divided by the numbers in the third column.



Air Condition
Part-
icle size (mi-crons)
Length of area right in front of lens (mi-
crons)



Blockage fraction (maximum size of natural orb as fraction of original photo width)Would you notice a photo orb caused by a natural particle suspended in air?
Outdoor air, dry1150000.00007 or 1/15000


No
Indoors, normal10150000.00067 or 1/1500


No
Indoor, dust spikes (vacuuming, etc.)50150000.0033 or 1/300


No
Outdoor heavy smog30150000.002 or 1/500


No
Thick fog or mist500150000.03 or 1/30Maybe
Heavy visible dust in air, reducing visibility500150000.03 or 1/30Maybe
Rain1000 or more150000.07 or moreMaybe

This table tells us how absurd is the notion that dust particles in ordinary outdoor air are sufficient to produce orbs in photographs. Since such particles cannot block more than about 1/15000 (one fifteen thousandth) of the original photo width, they are many times too small to produce noticeable orbs in photos. This table also tells us that dust particles in ordinary indoor air are way too small to produce orbs in photos. Such particles cannot block more than about 1/1500 (one fifteen hundredth) of the original photo width.

I have never taken photos in dusty air or misty air except for a handful of photos in posts specifically devoted to the topic of whether dusty air or misty air can produce mysterious orbs. For a full explanation of why dust, water vapor and pollen cannot explain mysterious orbs, see my long post "The Math Showing That Orbs Are Not Dust, Pollen, or Water Vapor" which you can read here. 

I have most abundantly got in my photos mysterious orbs with stripes, including many photos showing a repetition of mysterious orb stripe patterns (as you can see in my post here). You can use the link here to see more than 750 of my original posts showing mysterious striped orbs that I photographed in clean, dry air. Using that link to see the whole set of photos requires repeatedly pressing the Older Posts button at the bottom right of the page. An easier way to view the great majority of such photos is to use the link here, which takes you to my year 2020 free online book "800 Mysterious Striped Orbs: A Paranormal Phenomenon." The book can be very conveniently read by finger-swiping, after you press the [] icon at the bottom of the page viewer. 

Faced with this abundant reality of mysterious striped orbs, the skeptic is frustrated and befuddled. It is all too clear that his standard explanation attempt of dust does not work. Who ever heard of striped dust? I doubt that such a term was ever used before I started to publish my photos of mysterious striped orbs. 

When I published on Facebook my latest photo of a mysterious striped orb (which was also another repetition of a highly recurring "inverted Y" pattern in mysterious striped orbs), I got some comments making laughable attempts to explain away the mysterious effect. Some claimed that there was a smudge on my camera lens. Others claimed that my camera lens was cracked. 

I can give a simple explanation of why such ideas fail completely. The reason is that if you have either a cracked lens or a smudge on your camera lens, you will have a situation where the photographic anomaly would continue to persist, photo after photo after photo. But no such situation existed; and the next photo showed no such anomaly. Almost invariably (in much greater than 99% of cases), when I get a mysterious striped orb in my photo, I will see no such anomaly in the next photo I take. 

I can give some schematic drawings to help explain this point. Imagine you somehow at 12:24 PM get a smudge on your camera lens. Taking a photo of your living room, you might get something that looks rather like this, with the smudge being the mark on the top right. 


Now what is your photo going to look like when you take the very next photo of the same spot? You will continue to see exactly the same smudge. So the next photo of the same spot would look like this:


And the effect would continue until you wiped your camera lens to clean the smudge. But no such thing goes on when I photograph mysterious orbs in clean dry air. Instead there will be one photo showing the mysterious orb; and the next photo will show no such thing. 

If you had a cracked lens (perhaps caused by dropping your camera), you might take a photo of your living room, and suddenly notice an anomaly like this (the crack is depicted in the top right):


There would be no fix for the anomaly without replacing the lens. The next photo of the same spot would look like this:


And each photo you took would show the same anomaly in the upper right of your photo, because there is no way to fix a cracked lens by wiping your camera lens. 

In the years I have been publishing photos on this blog, I have never got any such thing as a camera lens crack. Years ago I once got a little bit of a smudge on my camera lens. It looked nothing like an orb, and nothing like a mysterious striped orbs. Smudges on a camera lens don't look like mysterious striped orbs; they look like shadowy smudges. 

On this blog I have published more than 4000 posts labeled "air orb" and more than 750 posts labeled "striped air orb." In well over 99% of the photos included in these posts (photos taken in clean dry air), there was never any reappearance of an orb anomaly in the next photo taken after the published photo.  In the extremely tiny fraction of the times when I got a reappearance (much less than 1%), I would publish the photo showing the reappearance. 

When photographing falling drops of pure, clean water, I have very, very often got dramatic pattern reappearances, but not any type that can be explained by a camera crack or a camera smudge. Instead, what I very, very often got when photographing falling water drops is several or quite a few reappearances of a pattern in the same photo, with the multiple reappearances of the pattern persisting for quite a few or many consecutive photos on a single day. Such an effect would never persist from one day to the next.  My free online book here documents that effect in exhaustive detail, and the book includes thousands of photos showing the effect.  Below is one example, from my post here.  We see in the same photo three repetitions of the same five-part pattern.  You can see 700+ of my original posts documenting this effect, using the link here. The posts were published before there were any good AI image generators. 

five-part orb pattern

No comments:

Post a Comment